Chinese EV Maker Nio Hits the Brakes on New Sell Rating

Cars and Drivers

Published: July 17, 2020 11:47 am

Shares of Shanghai-based electric vehicle (EV) maker Nio Inc. (NYSE: NIO) plunged more than 17% Friday morning following a downgrade by Goldman Sachs analyst Fei Fang, who cut the company’s rating from Neutral to Sell and chopped Nio’s price target nearly in half.

Last week, Goldman boosted its 12-month price target on Tesla Inc. (NASDAQ: TSLA) stock to $1,300 per share. The stock closed above $1,500 on Thursday and has added another 0.7% in Friday trading.

In late April, Nio announced an investment of RMB7 billion ($990 million) from a group of investors, including the city and provincial government entities, in Nio China, a new entity that will be majority-owned by Nio, with the other investors owning less than a quarter of the shares.

At the time of the April announcement, Nio stock traded at around $3.60 per American depositary share (ADS). By July 1, the ADSs had climbed to $7.90 and doubled again to post a 52-week high of $16.44 last week. That’s too far, too fast, to summarize Fang’s reason for the downgrade.

In early June, Fang upgraded Nio from Neutral to Buy with a price target of $6.40. It appears that the $990 million investment played a significant role in that upgrade. He seemed particularly impressed by the fact that Nio had become the first domestic premium brand to have generated a waiting list of Chinese customers.

By late June, Fang dropped his Buy rating to Neutral again while lifting his price target to $7. Nio had raised some $475 million in a secondary offering at $5.95 a share.

Nio’s shares continued to soar as June turned to July, and Fang has finally declared a halt. With consensus price target Thursday night of $38.65, the stock’s implied upside was nearly 200%. And that’s on a stock that is expected to post a net loss of $6.25 this year and $4.30 next year.

The carmaker has shown no evidence that sales volume will increase or that profits are due anytime soon, according to Fang. He still believes Nio’s long-term story is a good one because China continues to back EV adoption and because Chinese buyers tend to like premium vehicles.

Nio’s ADSs traded down about 12.6% shortly before noon Friday, at $11.31 in a 52-week range of $1.19 to $16.44. One Nio ADS is equal to one ordinary share.

24/7 Wall St.
7 Unpopular Value Stocks That Could Surge Into 2021

Travel Cards Are Getting Too Good To Ignore (sponsored)

Credit card companies are pulling out all the stops, with the issuers are offering insane travel rewards and perks.

We’re talking huge sign-up bonuses, points on every purchase, and benefits like lounge access, travel credits, and free hotel nights. For travelers, these rewards can add up to thousands of dollars in flights, upgrades, and luxury experiences every year.

It’s like getting paid to travel — and it’s available to qualified borrowers who know where to look.

We’ve rounded up some of the best travel credit cards on the market. Click here to see the list. Don’t miss these offers — they won’t be this good forever.