Commodities & Metals

S&P Walked Away From Rio Tinto (RTP, BHP)

Standard & Poors took an already unenthusiastic "Hold" rating on U.K.-based metals giant Rio Tinto (NYSE:RTP) ADR’s down to the beloved "Sell" rating.  This was after a 29% pre-market gain in share prices based on the Australia-based BHP Billiton (NYSE:BHP) unsolicited offer to acquire the company in a stock for stock swap.  This would value Rio Tinto at $414 per share.  Rio Tinto did reject the offer with the statement that it undervalued the price for the company.  S&P said that based upon the assumption that Billiton will ultimately buy it, S&P raised its $250 target to $438 per ADR.  Since the value was above the target, S&P says sell. 

24/7 Wall St. thinks there is a much larger issue than today’s call from S&P, regardless of when their call came. Rio Tinto plc closed up 23% at $440.20 in regular trading, above the prior $376.40 high over the last year.  Shares are up more than 300% since mid-2004.  And this is ‘undervalued’? As of today’s close, BHP’s market cap was $218 Billion and RTP’s market cap was $141 Billion (after the gain).

We aren’t sure which government or international agency out there should be blocking these giant mergers, but realistically 24/7 Wall St. wonders just how big these metals companies will be allowed to grow to before everyone realizes that metals prices of any real size will be a supply-controlled market ruled by price-fixing.  That will not be a good development for anyone other than the conglomerate mining and commodity monopolies.

Jon C. Ogg
November 8, 2007

Jon Ogg produces the Special Situation Investing Newsletter; he does not own securities in the companies he covers.

It’s Your Money, Your Future—Own It (sponsor)

Retirement can be daunting, but it doesn’t need to be.

Imagine having an expert in your corner to help you with your financial goals. Someone to help you determine if you’re ahead, behind, or right on track. With SmartAsset, that’s not just a dream—it’s reality. This free tool connects you with pre-screened financial advisors who work in your best interests. It’s quick, it’s easy, so take the leap today and start planning smarter!

Don’t waste another minute; get started right here and help your retirement dreams become a retirement reality.

Thank you for reading! Have some feedback for us?
Contact the 24/7 Wall St. editorial team.

AI Portfolio

Discover Our Top AI Stocks

Our expert who first called NVIDIA in 2009 is predicting 2025 will see a historic AI breakthrough.

You can follow him investing $500,000 of his own money on our top AI stocks for free.