Arch Coal Inc. (NYSE: ACI) was a Hail Mary call in our stock picks that could double in 2014, mostly as the least ugly piglet of the small cap coal stocks. We had decided to remove Arch from that list of potential doubles prior to the Tuesday earnings report. Even with shares having reacted positively, we still think that the time for this to be a likely double has come and gone.

Normally you would expect to hear good news and a favorable outlook when you see a stock rise more than 5% after earnings. The problem is that Arch Coal is losing money, just losing less than analysts were expecting. Revenue was a tad light on expectations, and Arch again lowered expectations for sales volume and capital spending for 2014.

The net loss was $96.9 million. This translated to -$0.46 in earnings (loss) per share. If you adjust for one-time and special items, then suddenly the loss of $0.29 per share looks far better than the -$0.48 per share expected by analysts. Revenue was down almost 7% to $713.8 million, versus the $716 million expected.

ALSO READ: 6 Analyst Stock Picks Under $10 With Massive Upside

The company’s message is that it expects strong cost performance to continue and that it will remain nimble versus market conditions. The reality is that coal’s negative trends are deeply entrenched, and there just seems to be no help whatsoever from any outside forces. The current energy targets from the White House, DOE and EPS just are not favorable to coal. That is more likely rather than less likely to continue.

It was back on July 21 that we formally removed Arch Coal from the list of stocks that could double in 2014. Sure, anything is possible. That being said, the turnaround that looked possible did start but it fizzled out. The inclusion price was at $4.10 in early February, and Arch Coal shares did rise to just over $5.00. That didn’t last, and as the stock slid and slid to about $3, its chance of a double in 2014 sure seems to have all but died.

The final straw for us was the news of yet another complex being idled. This means that a Hail Mary turnaround pass into the end zone turned into an interception. Our one word of caution for investors who want to try to remain in the bullish camp: you sure better use put options as a hedge against the industry woes to prove that sanity can help counterbalance unrealistic optimism.

Arch Coal shares were up almost 65 at $3.02 in Tuesday’s mid-day trading. The gain after earnings just is not enough of a recovery to make us look at the company in much more of a positive light than the pre-earnings viewpoint. In fact, it wasn’t an improvement at all. It was just less bad than what analysts had braced clients for.

ALSO READ: Large Cap Stocks That Are Being Sold Now by Mutual Funds

Thank you for reading! Have some feedback for us?
Contact the 24/7 Wall St. editorial team.