Gun control laws are designed and implemented, in part, to keep firearms out of the wrong hands. These laws, largely set at the state level, include universal background checks that close the so-called gun show loophole, restrictions for individuals with a history of certain mental health issues, licensing requirements, and bans or restrictions on types of firearms commonly used in mass shootings or other crimes.
24/7 Wall St. Key Points:
Gun control laws in the U.S. are set largely at the state level.
The resulting patchwork of firearm regulations across the 50 states is helping to fuel an interstate market for gun trafficking.
In the states that have these and other gun control laws, law-abiding citizens still have little difficulty accessing firearms for legitimate, legal purposes. The same cannot be said for those with criminal records seeking to obtain a firearm for the wrong reasons.
In states that have done little to regulate gun sales, however, it can be far easier for prohibited persons to access firearms. These inconsistencies have helped fuel an interstate black market for firearms. The transfer of guns across state borders for illicit purposes is evidenced by tracing data from the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives.
Federal firearm tracings offer a rough approximation of gun crime. When firearms are recovered at a crime scene or taken from a suspect, they are often reported to the ATF for tracing. In these cases, the ATF assists in criminal investigations by using serial numbers and other markings to determine when and where a firearm was originally purchased. While not all guns traced by the ATF were used in a crime — and not all firearms used for illicit purposes are traced — federal tracing data offers valuable insight into gun violence trends in the United States.
Using 2023 ATF firearm tracing data, 24/7 Wall St. identified the states with the worst gun trafficking problem. States are ranked by the share of firearms traced by the ATF that were originally purchased in a different state.
Among the 50 states, the share of traced firearms that were originally sourced from a different state ranges from 15% to over 80%. The states where the largest share of firearms that were linked to a crime in 2023 were sourced from a different state tend to have strong gun control laws, while many of the states where a relatively small share of traced guns came from out-of-state have adopted a hands-off approach to firearm regulations. (Here is a look at the U.S. states with the highest rates of gun theft.)
The gun violence prevention group Giffords Law Center assigns each state a letter grade rating the strength of their firearm laws. Grades range from “A,” for the states with the strongest laws, to “F,” for the states with the weakest. Of the 10 states where the largest share of traced firearms came from out-of-state, nine have a gun law grade of “A” or “A-“. Meanwhile, eight of the 10 lowest ranking states on this list have a grade of “D-” or lower. (Here is a look at the states with the most restrictive gun laws.)
In addition to their public safety goals, gun control laws have substantial economic implications. The disparities in state-level firearm regulations fuel an illicit market that burdens not only public safety but also the economy. States with weaker laws contribute to increased trafficking, driving up law enforcement and judicial expenses in both the source and receiving states. Furthermore, these illegal activities undermine legitimate businesses, including firearm retailers, and exert pressure on resources geared toward crime prevention and public health.
On the other hand, states with strong gun control laws may see reduced crime-related expenses, potentially fostering a more stable economic environment while improving consumer trust in legal markets. Ultimately, gun policy reform can be a powerful tool in reducing the economic toll of violence and trafficking across the country.
Why It Matters
Gun control laws are put in place, in part, to help keep firearms out of the wrong hands — and in the U.S., these laws are set largely at the state level. While some states have implemented strong gun safety laws, others have not. In theory, criminals will have greater difficulty obtaining a firearm in states where guns are tightly regulated. Partially as a result, in many of the states with strict gun control laws, thousands of guns that are linked to crime are ultimately determined to have originally been purchased in another part of the country.
50. Texas
Firearms linked to crime sourced from out of state, 2023: 15.0% of traced guns (7,169 total guns)
Top out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Louisiana; 1,150 guns, 2.4% of all recovered firearms in Texas
2nd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Oklahoma; 497 guns, 1.0% of all recovered firearms in Texas
3rd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Mississippi; 486 guns, 1.0% of all recovered firearms in Texas
Texas’s gun law strength grade: F
49. Wisconsin
Firearms linked to crime sourced from out of state, 2023: 15.1% of traced guns (1,074 total guns)
Top out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Illinois; 180 guns, 2.5% of all recovered firearms in Wisconsin
2nd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Indiana; 83 guns, 1.2% of all recovered firearms in Wisconsin
3rd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Texas; 76 guns, 1.1% of all recovered firearms in Wisconsin
Wisconsin’s gun law strength grade: C
48. Ohio
Firearms linked to crime sourced from out of state, 2023: 15.6% of traced guns (2,801 total guns)
Top out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Kentucky; 495 guns, 2.8% of all recovered firearms in Ohio
2nd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Indiana; 305 guns, 1.7% of all recovered firearms in Ohio
3rd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: West Virginia; 216 guns, 1.2% of all recovered firearms in Ohio
Ohio’s gun law strength grade: D-
47. Alaska
Firearms linked to crime sourced from out of state, 2023: 15.8% of traced guns (207 total guns)
Top out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Colorado; 26 guns, 2.0% of all recovered firearms in Alaska
2nd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Florida; 15 guns, 1.1% of all recovered firearms in Alaska
3rd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Texas; 14 guns, 1.1% of all recovered firearms in Alaska
Alaska’s gun law strength grade: F
46. Alabama
Firearms linked to crime sourced from out of state, 2023: 16.0% of traced guns (1,429 total guns)
Top out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Georgia; 303 guns, 3.4% of all recovered firearms in Alabama
2nd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Florida; 186 guns, 2.1% of all recovered firearms in Alabama
3rd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Mississippi; 171 guns, 1.9% of all recovered firearms in Alabama
Alabama’s gun law strength grade: F
45. Arizona
Firearms linked to crime sourced from out of state, 2023: 16.5% of traced guns (1,903 total guns)
Top out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: California; 237 guns, 2.0% of all recovered firearms in Arizona
2nd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Texas; 213 guns, 1.8% of all recovered firearms in Arizona
3rd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: New Mexico; 129 guns, 1.1% of all recovered firearms in Arizona
Arizona’s gun law strength grade: F
44. Virginia
Firearms linked to crime sourced from out of state, 2023: 17.5% of traced guns (2,155 total guns)
Top out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: North Carolina; 364 guns, 3.0% of all recovered firearms in Virginia
2nd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Florida; 193 guns, 1.6% of all recovered firearms in Virginia
3rd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Georgia; 170 guns, 1.4% of all recovered firearms in Virginia
Virginia’s gun law strength grade: B+
43. Indiana
Firearms linked to crime sourced from out of state, 2023: 17.6% of traced guns (1,931 total guns)
Top out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Kentucky; 371 guns, 3.4% of all recovered firearms in Indiana
2nd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Ohio; 204 guns, 1.9% of all recovered firearms in Indiana
3rd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Illinois; 190 guns, 1.7% of all recovered firearms in Indiana
Indiana’s gun law strength grade: D-
42. Georgia
Firearms linked to crime sourced from out of state, 2023: 18.1% of traced guns (3,646 total guns)
Top out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Florida; 656 guns, 3.3% of all recovered firearms in Georgia
2nd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Alabama; 583 guns, 2.9% of all recovered firearms in Georgia
3rd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: South Carolina; 435 guns, 2.2% of all recovered firearms in Georgia
Georgia’s gun law strength grade: F
41. New Hampshire
Firearms linked to crime sourced from out of state, 2023: 18.8% of traced guns (124 total guns)
Top out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Maine; 28 guns, 4.2% of all recovered firearms in New Hampshire
2nd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Vermont; 14 guns, 2.1% of all recovered firearms in New Hampshire
3rd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Massachusetts; 13 guns, 2.0% of all recovered firearms in New Hampshire
New Hampshire’s gun law strength grade: D-
40. Missouri
Firearms linked to crime sourced from out of state, 2023: 19.1% of traced guns (1,736 total guns)
Top out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Kansas; 518 guns, 5.7% of all recovered firearms in Missouri
2nd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Illinois; 217 guns, 2.4% of all recovered firearms in Missouri
3rd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Texas; 142 guns, 1.6% of all recovered firearms in Missouri
Missouri’s gun law strength grade: F
39. Florida
Firearms linked to crime sourced from out of state, 2023: 20.0% of traced guns (6,298 total guns)
Top out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Georgia; 1,251 guns, 4.0% of all recovered firearms in Florida
2nd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Alabama; 498 guns, 1.6% of all recovered firearms in Florida
3rd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Texas; 451 guns, 1.4% of all recovered firearms in Florida
Florida’s gun law strength grade: C-
38. Michigan
Firearms linked to crime sourced from out of state, 2023: 20.8% of traced guns (1,933 total guns)
Top out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Ohio; 288 guns, 3.1% of all recovered firearms in Michigan
2nd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Indiana; 183 guns, 2.0% of all recovered firearms in Michigan
3rd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Kentucky; 163 guns, 1.8% of all recovered firearms in Michigan
Michigan’s gun law strength grade: B-
37. South Carolina
Firearms linked to crime sourced from out of state, 2023: 21.0% of traced guns (2,453 total guns)
Top out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: North Carolina; 700 guns, 6.0% of all recovered firearms in South Carolina
2nd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Georgia; 530 guns, 4.5% of all recovered firearms in South Carolina
3rd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Florida; 170 guns, 1.5% of all recovered firearms in South Carolina
Firearms linked to crime sourced from out of state, 2023: 80.7% of traced guns (6,280 total guns)
Top out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Georgia; 954 guns, 12.3% of all recovered firearms in New York
2nd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Virginia; 634 guns, 8.1% of all recovered firearms in New York
3rd out-of-state source for guns linked to crime: Pennsylvania; 599 guns, 7.7% of all recovered firearms in New York
New York’s gun law strength grade: A
It’s Your Money, Your Future—Own It (sponsor)
Retirement can be daunting, but it doesn’t need to be.
Imagine having an expert in your corner to help you with your financial goals. Someone to help you determine if you’re ahead, behind, or right on track. With SmartAsset, that’s not just a dream—it’s reality. This free tool connects you with pre-screened financial advisors who work in your best interests. It’s quick, it’s easy, so take the leap today and start planning smarter!
Don’t waste another minute; get started right here and help your retirement dreams become a retirement reality.