Health and Healthcare

This Is the Safest State to Be In as COVID-19 Cases Soar

Douglas A. McIntyre

Published: November 6, 2020 7:13 am

Confirmed COVID-19 cases in the United States soared by over 100,000 yesterday and the total figure is almost 9.7 million. There are fears that the daily confirmed case rate will rise above 100,000 most days. Fatal cases reached 238,516 after rising by 1,144. It has been months since deaths crossed the 1,000 a day level. The presence of confirmed and fatal cases can be extremely different from state to state. One state is clearly the safest right now, based on confirmed cases per 100,000 people. It is also the state with the lowest number of total cases.

The confirmed case count in Vermont is 3.4 per 100,000, based on the daily average of the past seven days. That contrasts to 157.4 per 100,000 in hardest-hit North Dakota. The number of fatal cases in Vermont is so low that it does not make sense statistically to use the “per 100,000 people” measure. The death rate by that yardstick is highest in North Dakota at 1.5.

Vermont is also in the region where the spread of the disease is slowest. The Northeast was hit hard early, in March and April. Most of the devastation in the areas was in New York, Connecticut and Massachusetts, while Vermont, Maine and New Hampshire suffered much less. Across the entire area, confirmed case counts have risen slowly in the past several days compared with other regions.

The spread of the disease most recently has been extremely aggressive in the Mountain States and Midwest. The rate of confirmed cases increases in North and South Dakota, Wisconsin, Nebraska, Montana and Idaho have been described as out of control.

The number of confirmed cases on an absolute basis is also the lowest in Vermont by far. It is currently 2,303. Maine is the second lowest at 7,260, and the third lowest is New Hampshire at 11,808. Vermont is the second-smallest state by population at 623,989. Wyoming is the least populated state at 578,759, but it has 15,409 confirmed cases.

Why is the Vermont count so low when other small states by population in the West are so much worse off? Its measures to control the disease have been so effective that Dr. Anthony Fauci has mentioned it as a model for other states.

The first reason is likely that people in the state are healthy in general. It has a relatively low number of people who are obese, one of the factors in people who are particularly hard hit by the disease and die more often compared with people of normal weight. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has measured obesity in Vermont as among the lowest across the 50 states and Puerto Rico.

People in the state also have been particularly strict in social distancing and mask wearing. Part of this is because of the state-regulated size of gatherings and closing schools and restaurants.

Unfortunately, most states have ignored Dr. Fauci’s advice and have not taken the same measures Vermont has. While the measures have made Vermont safe, the lack of them elsewhere has helped fuel the recent rapid spread of the disease.