Jobs

When Jobs Reports Conflict: ADP Jobs Growth Strong, TrimTabs Sees Awful Jobs Market

Friday’s key Labor Department report on unemployment and payrolls will be highly watched, and we have two nongovernmental reports that could significantly change those expectations. The ADP report for July looked good on the surface, with the U.S. economy adding some 200,000 payrolls during the month. Dow Jones was calling for 183,000 and Bloomberg was calling for 179,000 as the consensus estimates. Where the problem arises is that TrimTabs also released its own report on the jobs market, and this outfit projects that the U.S. really only added 23,000 payrolls in July.

Either number could be considered an estimate-changing report. Friday’s unemployment rate is expected to have fallen to 7.5% in July from 7.6% in June. Its nonfarm payrolls is expected to be up 175,000, and the payrolls from the more important private sector are expected to be up by 187,000, according to Bloomberg.

Imagine what happens when economists see one number come in much higher at 200,000 and then one come in at a dismal 23,000. Now Friday’s report is a real wild card. We also have an FOMC decision on interest rates to deal with as well, and the market will be hanging on every word to see if Ben Bernanke and the Federal Reserve will start tapering their bond purchases of $85 billion each month sooner rather than later.

TrimTabs showed that July was the worst month since September 2010, when the U.S. lost 65,000 jobs. TrimTabs also reported that wages and salaries in July rose by only 0.4% year-over year, and they think that is consistent with an economy that is close to stalling. TrimTabs points out that its data are historically more relevant because its reports on the jobs estimates are based on daily income tax deposits into the U.S. Treasury.

Keep in mind that the confidence numbers have been mixed. Also need to keep in mind that if economic news is too strong, particularly on the labor reports, then Bernanke and the Federal Reserve will be perceived as having enough justification to begin tapering that $85 billion per month in bond purchases. After a while, they even will have justification to begin raising interest rates.

 

Thank you for reading! Have some feedback for us?
Contact the 24/7 Wall St. editorial team.