Personal Finance

The 3 Social Security Mistakes to Avoid

Social Security Card with cash money dollar bills - living on a fixed income, benefits SSN
MargJohnsonVA / Shutterstock.com

President Franklin Roosevelt’s June 1934 Executive Order established the Committee on Economic Safety. That led to the Social Security Act, passed on Aug. 14, 1935. 

Social Security provided social insurance for older Americans, financed through payroll taxes paid by employees and their employers. Working people earned retirement benefits based on their average covered earnings. You could not receive benefits while earning income. Spouses and children weren’t eligible. 

Nearly 90 years later, approximately 180 million worked in Social Security-covered employment in 2023, with 67 million receiving monthly benefits as of September 2023. Social Security has become a crucial part of American workers’ retirement, with 20% of beneficiaries totally dependent on this source of income for their financial survival.   

Like most retirement programs, a little financial planning goes a long way to maximizing social security benefits. 

Here are three Social Security mistakes to avoid as you prepare for retirement. 

Claiming Too Early

Fort Collins, CO people | cyclist on biking trail in Colorado foothills
marekuliasz / iStock via Getty Images
Americans can begin collecting Social Security as early as 62. However, if you elect to receive it early, your monthly benefits will be cut by 30% compared to waiting until 70. Your benefits are estimated to increase by 5-8% annually for every year you delay taking it between 62 and 70.

Reasons you might claim early include the need to live on them and a shorter life expectancy. A mistaken reason to claim Social Security early is that you believe the benefits won’t be there when you need them due to the Social Security trust fund running short. 

“Following the herd about misconceptions and fear-mongering about Social Security ‘running out of money’ creates fear that people will lose their Social Security benefit, so a lot of people elect to receive Social Security early at 62,” Bankrate.com reported comments from Nick Strain, senior wealth advisor at Halbert Hargrove, a California-based financial advisor.  

A 2022 report from Boston University and the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta estimated that the average amount a typical worker loses in lifetime discretionary income by claiming before 70 is $182,000

Given that approximately 25% of Americans claim Social Security at age 62 and nearly half before age 70, many people are missing out on greater retirement income.

Not Coordinating With Spouse

fizkes / iStock via Getty Images
If you and your spouse live in a one-income household, unless you need the monthly income, you would be better off delaying taking social security benefits until you reach age 70. However, if you both work, financial planners suggest it’s best for the lower-earning spouse to take the benefits sooner if needed, with the higher earner forgoing benefits until age 70.   

Also, it’s vital in a two-income household to consider each wage earner’s lifetime income. If the gap is wide enough, it might make sense for the lower earner to switch to a spousal rather than a retirement benefit. 

The spousal benefit was created years ago and designed for a society with primarily one-income households. A spouse who didn’t work could apply for the benefit, which paid out up to half the working spouse’s monthly benefit. 

Although a spouse could claim spousal benefits at 62, waiting until your full retirement age or FRA is better. If you were born in 1960 or later, your FRA is 67. So, if, for example, your spouse’s FRA is $2,000 monthly, at 67, you’d get $1,000 (50%) in spousal benefits. However, if you take them at 62, your monthly spousal benefit drops to $650 (32.50%).

If you’re married, it pays to have this discussion with your spouse before you get to 62.

Earning Too Much

Income tax, tax collection, financial concept : The word tax with a photo of US President George Washington on a one-dollar bill. Tax is a Compulsory payment to government based on income or wealth.
William Potter / Shutterstock.com
While you might enjoy your job and want to keep working past 62, you will be penalized. The Social Security Administration calls this the “earnings test.” In 2024, if you collect Social Security benefits before age 67, you will lose $1 of benefits for every $2 earned over $22,230 or $1,860 monthly. 

Interestingly, the Social Security rules have an “adjustment of reduction factor (ARF)” that gives you back the lost benefits when you reach 67. 

“Know that it’s a good thing to lose money to the earnings test because for every dollar you lose to the earnings test, you get about about roughly $1.20 back in benefits,” CBS reported Boston University economist Laurence Kotlikoff’s comments on the subject in November 2023. 

“But people aren’t being told that, so they mistakenly think that going back to work just makes no sense because all they’re doing is working for the government.”

So, if you like what you’re doing, work past 62.

Get Ready To Retire (Sponsored)

Start by taking a quick retirement quiz from SmartAsset that will match you with up to 3 financial advisors that serve your area and beyond in 5 minutes, or less.

Each advisor has been vetted by SmartAsset and is held to a fiduciary standard to act in your best interests.

Here’s how it works:
1. Answer SmartAsset advisor match quiz
2. Review your pre-screened matches at your leisure. Check out the advisors’ profiles.
3. Speak with advisors at no cost to you. Have an introductory call on the phone or introduction in person and choose whom to work with in the future

Get started right here.

Thank you for reading! Have some feedback for us?
Contact the 24/7 Wall St. editorial team.