Buying a second home can be a big decision as you’re making a commitment of both time and money. One Reddit poster is deciding whether he wants to make this commitment. He posted recently sharing details on his numbers and asking for advice on whether spending big money on a luxury property made sense given his financial situation and goals. 

So, should he move forward with the purchase? Let’s take a look at his situation for more insight. 

With $30 million in investments, does buying a second home make sense?

The Reddit poster explained some details about his finances when he asked whether he should purchase a home. He’s 50 years old, married to someone the same age, with no children. They have somewhere around $7.25 million in illiquid private stock with an uncertain valuation. They also have $500,000 in cash, $20 million in an IRA and brokerage account with conservative investments, a $2 million primary home with no debt, and a $2 million rental property that they owe $500K on. 

His question is whether he should spend around $5 million to buy a luxury vacation property in an area where they plan to spend four to six months each year after retiring. He’d either withdraw the money from his $20 million in investments or could take a mortgage to pay for it, and he potentially could rent out the property when he isn’t using it to recoup some of the costs.

While he feels like this plan might be a viable one, he also wanted to make sure he wasn’t missing anything. 

The Reddit poster should buy the home and enjoy his hard work

A quick look at the Redditor’s numbers shows that it’s very clear he can afford to buy the home. 

Even if he pays for the property in cash — which he may want to do given the high mortgage interest rates currently available — he’d be left with $15 million. At a 3.7% safe withdrawal rate, this would produce $555,000 in annual income. Without housing debt, it seems very likely that the OP should easily be able to live off that much income — especially since his investment property produces $100K in income. 

The only remaining questions, then, will be whether purchasing the property will be a good fit for his lifestyle and something he enjoys.

Some Redditors suggested that he rent in the area first to make certain that he likes living there and to confirm that he and his wife will end up spending a sufficient amount of time there. This may not be a bad idea depending on how familiar he is with the area, as the transaction costs on a $5 million property are high so he could risk losing money if he had to sell soon after he bought because it turned out he didn’t like the property as much as he thought. 

If he’s confident that he will enjoy the area, though, then he shouldn’t hesitate to move forward with finding and buying a property he loves. He’s obviously worked hard to build such a big nest egg. Now that he’s at the end of his career, he deserves to spend his money to enjoy his life — including buying the home of his dreams in a luxury destination where he can spend his retirement years. 

Thank you for reading! Have some feedback for us?
Contact the 24/7 Wall St. editorial team.