Special Report
24 Milkshakes With More Calories Than an Entire Meal
Published:
Milkshakes have been around since at least the late 19th century — there was mention of an “an Atlanta drink” called “milk shake,” in the Atlanta Constitution in 1886. That prototype milkshake included just milk, crushed ice, “a mixture of unknown ingredients,” and “a bit of any desired sirup,” as the newspaper explained.” Eventually, people started using ice cream and cookies, creating a real caloric bomb, albeit an irresistibly delicious one.
Dieticians estimate Americans should break down their meal consumption throughout the day as follows: 300 to 400 calories for breakfast and 500 to 700 calories each for lunch and dinner, plus about 200 for snacks.
Most people are more likely to overeat rather than undereat, so 24/7 Tempo reviewed the menus of more than a dozen chain restaurants to compile a list of milkshakes that exceeded 700 calories. Calorie counts were taken either from the nutritional information provided by the chain on its website or from Nutrition Charts, a food nutrition data site.
Most places that make good shakes offer them in great variety, going beyond just the classic chocolate, strawberry, and vanilla. Bits of cookie, candy, even cake get mixed into shakes, which significantly add to the total caloric amount.
Shakes became popular in the 1950s. They can still be found in just about every burger joint or diner in America — and this is the best diner in every state.
Many of the milkshakes at popular fast-food operations actually fall below the 700 number — but largely due to their size. If people order the mini or small version, they will most likely consume a drink with 400 to 700 calories. But who orders a mini shake?
Some shakes have calorie counts that not only exceed the standard for a single meal but come very close to the recommended intake for an entire day of about 2,000 calories. This is how long you need to exercise to burn off the calories from your favorite foods.
Click here for 24 milkshakes with more calories than an entire meal
1. Jamocha Handcrafted Shake (large)
> Chain: Arby’s
> Calories: 1,060
There are 350 calories in a snack-size Jamocha Handcrafted Shake, and 830 in a medium.
[in-text-ad]
2. Vanilla Handcrafted Shake (large)
> Chain: Arby’s
> Calories: 900
This is the “low-cal” entry among Arby’s shakes, with a snack serving coming in at 280 calories and a medium at 690.
3. OREO Cookies n’ Cream Milkshake (large)
> Chain: Baskin-Robbins
> Calories: 1,440
A person who wanted to meet a daily calorie goal of 2,000 could enjoy this extravagant shake and still eat one medium-size bagel all day, without butter or cream cheese. Period.
4. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Milkshake (large)
> Chain: Baskin-Robbins
> Calories: 1,520
Even a small serving of this shake exceeds 700 calories, at 760.
[in-text-ad-2]
5. Chocolate Oreo Cookie Shake
> Chain: Burger King
> Calories: 740
A shake the Burger King menu describes as simply an Oreo Shake (without added chocolate?) is also over the limit, at 720 calories.
[in-text-ad]
6. Oreo Milkshake
> Chain: Cheesecake Factory
> Calories: 1,630
This dinner house chain, famous for its extravagant portions, offers just four “creamy milkshake” varieties — chocolate, strawberry, vanilla, and Oreo — in one size only.
7. Chocolate Milkshake
> Chain: Cheesecake Factory
> Calories: 1,260
This calorie count for a chocolate shake without cookie or candy add-ins is higher than usual.
8. Vanilla Milkshake
> Chain: Cheesecake Factory
> Calories: 1,210
The Cheesecake Factory’s strawberry milkshake shares the same calorie count as this one.
[in-text-ad-2]
9. Reese’s Chocolate Peanut Butter Dream (large)
> Chain: Cold Stone Creamery
> Calories: 1,610
Cold Stone lists calorie counts for their milkshakes (which come in two sizes, regular and large) both with and without their “whipped topping” (made with hydrogenated palm, palm kernel, coconut, and/or cottonseed oil, corn syrup, and sugar, among other things). This number is without. With the topping, it would climb up to 1740.
10. Cake Batter ‘n Shake (large)
> Chain: Cold Stone Creamery
> Calories: 1,300
With whipped topping added, this shake reaches 1,440 calories.
[in-text-ad]
11. Milk and OREO Cookies (large)
> Chain: Cold Stone Creamery
> Calories: 1,280
Cold Stone lists just six varieties of shake. With two sizes and the whipped topping option, that adds up to 24 in all. Of that number, only one shake — the smaller, untopped Savory Strawberry, is under 700 calories.
12. Peanut Butter Shake (large)
> Chain: Dairy Queen
> Calories: 1,250
Dairy Queen’s shakes come in small, medium, and large — no snack or mini sizes.
13. Hot Fudge Shake (large)
> Chain: Dairy Queen
> Calories: 990
The chain takes a signature drink, adding whipped topping. A small shake has less than twice the calories, at just 430.
[in-text-ad-2]
14. Caramel Shake (large)
> Chain: Dairy Queen
> Calories: 980
Some 13 Dairy Queen shakes in all — including the three on this list — exceed 700 calories. The chain’s trademark Blizzards, which are soft-serve ice cream with various cookies, candies, or brownies blended in, also frequently contain more than the limit.
15. Oreo Shake with Whipped Topping (large)
> Chain: Jack in the Box
> Calories: 1,170
This chain’s “whipped topping” — made with fully hydrogenated palm kernel oil, sugar, and a bunch of things that end in “-ate” — is responsible for 110 calories of the 1,170. (An equivalent quantity of real whipped cream would come in slightly higher, at 124 calories.)
[in-text-ad]
16. Chocolate Shake with Whipped Topping (large)
> Chain: Jack in the Box
> Calories: 1,150
Get a smaller version of this shake — 16 ounces instead of 24 — and it’s a mere 800 calories.
17. Strawberry Shake with Whipped Topping
> Chain: Jack in the Box
> Calories: 1,120
Of the four varieties of shake on the Jack in the Box menu, each available in two sizes, the only one whose calorie count doesn’t exceed 700 is the smaller Vanilla Shake with Whipped Topping — and that’s 700 calories exactly.
18. Loaded Chocolate Cookies & Cream Shake
> Chain: Shake Shack
> Calories: 1,160
You know a chain with this name has got to be serious about shakes. Shake Shack lists 13 varieties (one size) on their nutritional chart, but only six on their menu. This is the biggest calorie bomb in both places.
[in-text-ad-2]
19. Black and White Shake
> Chain: Shake Shack
> Calories: 770
The only other shake on the Shake Shack menu besides this one that exceeds 700 calories is the plain chocolate version, at 750.
[in-text-ad]
20. Oreo and Reese’s Peanut Butter Master Shake (large)
> Chain: Sonic Drive-In
> Calories: 1,720
This is one of a special category Sonic calls Master Shakes — which it describes as classic shakes “made even more indulgent with premium flavors and ingredients.” Like all the chain’s shakes, it’s available in mini, small, medium, and large sizes.
21. Reese’s Peanut Butter Classic Shake (large)
> Chain: Sonic Drive-In
> Calories: 1,490
The absence of Oreos demotes this shake to the simple “classic” category, with a loss of 230 calories compared with its more masterful sibling.
22. Cheesecake Master Shake (large)
> Chain: Sonic Drive-In
> Calories: 1,230
Of Sonic’s nearly 50 shakes in various sizes, more than two dozen exceed 700 calories, and 15 of those come in at 1,000 or more.
[in-text-ad-2]
23. Nutella
> Chain: Steak ‘n Shake
> Calories: 820
Many of the offerings here involve mix-in ingredients like Oreos, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, M&Ms, and Heath, Snickers, and Kit Kat bars.
[in-text-ad]
24. Reese’s Chocolate PB (regular)
> Chain: Steak ‘n Shake
> Calories: 980
Some 21 Steak ‘n Shake milkshakes (the three here included) exceed the 700 calorie mark.
Want retirement to come a few years earlier than you’d planned? Or are you ready to retire now, but want an extra set of eyes on your finances?
Now you can speak with up to 3 financial experts in your area for FREE. By simply clicking here you can begin to match with financial professionals who can help you build your plan to retire early. And the best part? The first conversation with them is free.
Click here to match with up to 3 financial pros who would be excited to help you make financial decisions.
Thank you for reading! Have some feedback for us?
Contact the 24/7 Wall St. editorial team.