This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
The number of wrongfully convicted Americans who have been exonerated has been steadily rising since at least 1989, when the National Registry of Exonerations began closely tracking this trend.
Before 2012, it was rare to have more than 100 convictions overturned in any given year. But since then, the number of exonerations by year has ranged between 103 in 2013 to a record 183 in 2016, when a raft of convictions for drug sale or possession were overturned. (These are states where the most prisoners die.)
An average of three exonerations a week, more than double the rate in 2011, is the new normal. Part of the reason for this trend is an increase in scrutiny of prosecutorial procedures, especially in larger cities, according to a 2016 report in Time magazine. The number of exonerations also varies by state.
To determine the states with the most wrongly convicted people, 24/7 Wall St. reviewed data from The National Registry of Exonerations – a project of the Newkirk Center for Science & Society at University of California Irvine, the University of Michigan Law School and Michigan State University College of Law. States were ranked on the number of people incarcerated in the state who have been exonerated since 1989. Federal cases were excluded. Alaska and Hawaii did not have sufficient data and were also excluded. Data on exoneree compensation came from the Innocence Project, a nonprofit legal organization focused on wrongful convictions. Incarcerated population data came from the Bureau of Justice Statistics, and is for 2020.
Larger population states typically have the most overturned wrongful convictions, but that is not always the case. This suggests scrutiny of the judicial system varies across the country.
Illinois, the country’s sixth-largest state by population, leads with 505 exonerations since 1989. By comparison, Florida, the country’s third most populous state, has just 81 overturned wrongful convictions since 1989.
Another factor that may play a role is compensation. Not all states provide monetary compensation for exonerees. According to the Innocence Project, a dozen states, including South Carolina (No. 47 on the list), Arkansas (No. 39), and Kentucky (No. 32), have no wrongful conviction compensation laws.
The vast majority of states with no compensation rank in the bottom 25. To compare, Texas, which has the second most exonerations since 1989, compensates exonerees $80,000 per year of wrongful imprisonment.
In states where wrongfully convicted people get compensated, the amount and available social services to help exonerees reintegrate into society varies, and in some states it can be lacking. In some cases, states have so-called “private compensation bills” that deal with compensation on a case-by-case basis that can require exonerees to mount publicity campaigns and yet still be denied compensation, according to the Innocence Project. (See also, the number of bombings last year in every state.)
Here are the states where the most prisoners are exonerated.
48. New Hampshire
> Exonerations since 1989: 2
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 2,352 (#43 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 3.9 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 2.0 (#47 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: Up to $20,000
[in-text-ad]
47. Vermont
> Exonerations since 1989: 3
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 1,284 (#48 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 17.1 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 5.7 (#38 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $30,000-$60,000 per year
46. Delaware
> Exonerations since 1989: 4
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 4,710 (#40 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 58.3 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 14.6 (#2 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: No statute
45. Wyoming
> Exonerations since 1989: 4
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 2,087 (#45 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 30.4 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 7.6 (#30 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: No statute
[in-text-ad-2]
44. North Dakota
> Exonerations since 1989: 4
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 1,401 (#47 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 11.5 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 2.9 (#45 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: No statute
43. Maine
> Exonerations since 1989: 4
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 1,714 (#46 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 3.4 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 0.9 (#48 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: Up to $300,000
[in-text-ad]
42. South Dakota
> Exonerations since 1989: 5
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 3,250 (#42 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 18.2 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 3.6 (#44 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: No statute
41. Idaho
> Exonerations since 1989: 6
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 8,171 (#33 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 76.3 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 12.7 (#6 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $62,000 per year, $75,000 per year on death row, at least $25,000 per year they had to register as a sex offender
40. Rhode Island
> Exonerations since 1989: 6
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 2,227 (#44 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 27.0 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 4.6 (#42 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $50,000 per year
[in-text-ad-2]
39. Nebraska
> Exonerations since 1989: 9
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 5,306 (#39 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 101.5 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 11.3 (#13 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: Up to $500,000
38. South Carolina
> Exonerations since 1989: 9
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 16,157 (#23 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 88.4 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 9.8 (#21 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: No statute
[in-text-ad]
37. New Mexico
> Exonerations since 1989: 10
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 5,500 (#37 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 65.7 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 6.6 (#34 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: No statute
24/7 Wall St.
36. Colorado
> Exonerations since 1989: 11
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 16,168 (#22 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 86.9 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 7.9 (#29 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $70,000 per year
35. Arkansas
> Exonerations since 1989: 13
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 16,094 (#24 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 104.2 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 8.0 (#28 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: No statute
[in-text-ad-2]
34. West Virginia
> Exonerations since 1989: 14
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 6,044 (#36 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 143.0 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 10.2 (#20 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: Determined by the court
33. Montana
> Exonerations since 1989: 15
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 3,927 (#41 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 141.8 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 9.5 (#22 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $60,000 a year and $25,000 a year for additional years served on parole and/or registered as a sex offender
[in-text-ad]
32. Kansas
> Exonerations since 1989: 16
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 8,779 (#31 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 121.6 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 7.6 (#30 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $65,000 per year
24/7 Wall St.
31. Iowa
> Exonerations since 1989: 16
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 8,307 (#32 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 81.2 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 5.1 (#41 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: Up to $25,000 per year
30. Utah
> Exonerations since 1989: 18
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 5,446 (#38 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 105.9 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 5.9 (#37 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: Utah’s average annual non-agricultural payroll wage, up to a maximum of 15 years
[in-text-ad-2]
29. Minnesota
> Exonerations since 1989: 18
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 8,148 (#34 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 39.9 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 2.2 (#46 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $50,000 per year
28. Nevada
> Exonerations since 1989: 22
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 11,422 (#29 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 238.4 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 10.8 (#16 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: 1-10 years: $50,000 per year; 10-20 years: $75,000 per year; 20+ years: $100,000 per year
[in-text-ad]
27. Kentucky
> Exonerations since 1989: 22
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 18,552 (#20 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 214.4 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 9.3 (#24 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: No statute
26. Arizona
> Exonerations since 1989: 22
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 37,731 (#7 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 134.2 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 6.1 (#36 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: No statute
25. Oregon
> Exonerations since 1989: 23
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 12,753 (#28 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 89.2 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 3.9 (#43 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $65,000 per year, plus $25,000 per year of post-release supervision
[in-text-ad-2]
24. Mississippi
> Exonerations since 1989: 26
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 17,577 (#21 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 321.8 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 12.4 (#7 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $50,000 per year
23. Alabama
> Exonerations since 1989: 27
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 25,328 (#14 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 192.5 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 7.1 (#33 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $50,000 per year
[in-text-ad]
22. Connecticut
> Exonerations since 1989: 30
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 9,559 (#30 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 369.4 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 12.3 (#8 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $49,314-$131,506 per year
21. Tennessee
> Exonerations since 1989: 30
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 22,685 (#17 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 341.2 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 11.4 (#12 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: Up to $1,000,000
20. Oklahoma
> Exonerations since 1989: 40
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 22,462 (#18 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 377.0 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 9.4 (#23 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $175,000, if the exoneree did not plead guilty
[in-text-ad-2]
19. Indiana
> Exonerations since 1989: 41
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 23,944 (#15 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 354.5 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 8.7 (#26 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $50,000 per year
18. New Jersey
> Exonerations since 1989: 43
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 12,830 (#27 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 462.5 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 10.8 (#16 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $50,000 per year
[in-text-ad]
17. Maryland
> Exonerations since 1989: 44
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 15,623 (#26 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 659.7 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 13.5 (#3 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: Determined by the length incarcerated and the state’s most recent median income
16. Georgia
> Exonerations since 1989: 47
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 47,141 (#3 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 538.1 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 11.4 (#11 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: No statute
15. Washington
> Exonerations since 1989: 50
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 15,724 (#25 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 266.8 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 5.3 (#39 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $50,000 per year
[in-text-ad-2]
14. Missouri
> Exonerations since 1989: 52
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 23,062 (#16 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 626.3 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 12.0 (#10 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $50 per day
13. Virginia
> Exonerations since 1989: 64
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 31,838 (#10 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 582.6 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 9.1 (#25 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: 90% of the state’s per capita personal income for each year
[in-text-ad]
12. Wisconsin
> Exonerations since 1989: 66
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 20,298 (#19 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 472.5 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 7.2 (#32 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: Up to $5,000 per year, maximum of $25,000 total
11. North Carolina
> Exonerations since 1989: 70
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 29,461 (#12 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 909.9 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 13.0 (#4 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $50,000 per year
10. Louisiana
> Exonerations since 1989: 71
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 26,964 (#13 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 1,123 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 14.6 (#1 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $40,000 per year up to $400,000
[in-text-ad-2]
9. Massachusetts
> Exonerations since 1989: 81
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 6,762 (#35 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 1,084 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 12.9 (#5 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: Up to $1 million
8. Florida
> Exonerations since 1989: 81
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 81,027 (#2 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 916.4 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 11.3 (#13 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $50,000 per year
[in-text-ad]
7. Ohio
> Exonerations since 1989: 93
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 45,036 (#5 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 1,038 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 11.2 (#15 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $52,625.18 per year
6. Pennsylvania
> Exonerations since 1989: 108
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 39,357 (#6 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 1,322 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 12.2 (#9 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: No statute
5. Michigan
> Exonerations since 1989: 147
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 33,617 (#9 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 1,570 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 10.7 (#18 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $50,000 per year
[in-text-ad-2]
4. California
> Exonerations since 1989: 266
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 97,328 (#1 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 2,145 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 8.1 (#27 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $51,110 per year
3. New York
> Exonerations since 1989: 313
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 34,128 (#8 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 3,350 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 10.7 (#18 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: Determined by the court
[in-text-ad]
2. Texas
> Exonerations since 1989: 436
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 45,596 (#4 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 2,321 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 5.3 (#39 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: $80,000 per year
1. Illinois
> Exonerations since 1989: 505
> Incarcerated population, 2020: 29,729 (#11 highest out of 48)
> Total years lost: 3,326 years
> Avg years lost per exoneree: 6.5 (#35 highest out of 48)
> Compensation for exonerees: Up to five years: $85,350, 5-14 years: $170,000, over 14 years: $199,150
Essential Tips for Investing (Sponsored)
A financial advisor can help you understand the advantages and disadvantages of investment properties. Finding a qualified financial advisor doesn’t have to be hard. SmartAsset’s free tool matches you with up to three financial advisors who serve your area, and you can interview your advisor matches at no cost to decide which one is right for you. If you’re ready to find an advisor who can help you achieve your financial goals, get started now.
Investing in real estate can diversify your portfolio. But expanding your horizons may add additional costs. If you’re an investor looking to minimize expenses, consider checking out online brokerages. They often offer low investment fees, helping you maximize your profit.
Thank you for reading! Have some feedback for us?
Contact the 24/7 Wall St. editorial team.
Latest from 24/7
