Cars and Drivers

3 Reasons Why Renault Should Merge With Nissan

Douglas A. McIntyre

Published: March 29, 2018 6:40 am

Last Updated: January 12, 2020 1:57 am

In the past day, there have been rumors that Nissan and Renault may merge. The speculation was first reported by Bloomberg. One theory is that a merger would create a single stock to be traded on global markets. The other is that it is the handiwork of the longtime CEO of both companies, Carlos Ghosn. Neither of those is the primary reason. The need for scale in a global car market dominated by Volkswagen, Toyota Motor Corp. (NYSE: TM) and General Motors Co. (NYSE: GM) is.

There is already cross-ownership between the two companies because each owns shares in the other. Maybe that would make a deal easier. Ghosn is considered among the greatest car manufacturers of his generation.

More to the point, its three large rivals each produced about 10 million cars and light trucks last year. Renault made 3.4 million and Nissan made 5.6 million. VW, Toyota and GM have global manufacturing networks that allow them to make cars in one market and ship them to another. Their R&D and product development operations also can be leveraged worldwide. Some cars sold across the globe are made on one platform, which means more duplication of parts and assembly. And global branding also leads to marketing efficiency. A good example of this is the Toyota Prius.

Also, GM, Toyota and VW have model lines so large they can appeal across the demographic map. For instance, VW owns Audi and Porsche and nine other brands.

One sign that scale is terribly important in the car industry is the repeated effort of Fiat Chrysler Automobiles N.V. (NYSE: FCAU) CEO Sergio Marchionne to find a partner. He says he has had preliminary talks with several large companies. He even publicly proposed a merger with GM. Among the reasons was that a new company would have better access to capital. Presumably, a combined balance sheet would get better ratings from credit agencies. The combination also would allow for huge cost cuts.

Marchionne saw years ago what Ghosn sees now. Being midsized in the global car industry may be untenable over time.