HSBC (HBC) announced that its earnings fell 57% to $3.35 billion during the first half of the year. The largest bank in Europe was able to temper some of its deficit for bad loans by a strong showing in its investment bank. Loans to consumers and businesses fell apart at a frightening rate. The stock market was pleased that investment banking did well and pushed the HSBC stock up.
Barclays (BCS) also announced earnings, and they rose 10% from last year. The news from the firm was remarkably similar to the earnings release from HSBC. Investment banking saved the day.
Investment banking may have become the champion of earnings at large global financial firms but its ability to largely offset loans that are going sour is limited. Rising stocks and easier access to credit have made the corporate debt and equities markets active again. Once the stock market starts to peak, some of that business will slow.
Banks may be in for much worse credit write offs, at least according to a number of analysts that cover the industry. The concerns about commercial real estate loan defaults are rising. Many large building and shopping complexes were purchased in 2005, 2006, and early 2007 based on the assumption that a strong business and retail environment would support huge mortgages. That is turning out not to be the case.
Consumer credit is also deteriorating rapidly. Defaults on credit cards and car loans tend to track unemployment and joblessness is still rising fairly quickly in the US, UK, and EU. The employment market will probably not begin to right itself until the middle of 2010, and if businesses stay cautious it may be much later.
Bank earnings for the first half and second quarter have been better than some analysts expected. A lot of the numbers were based on one-time benefits which are not likely to be repeated, but the real enemy of future earnings is that loans made three and four years ago are becoming more and more shaky and even robust investment banking figures will provide earnings to offset the effects of that.
Douglas A. McIntyre