S&P 500
7,226.20
+0.01%
Dow Jones
49,494.60
-0.62%
Nasdaq 100
27,685.40
+0.66%
Russell 2000
2,804.78
-0.02%
FTSE 100
10,364.50
0.00%
Nikkei 225
59,260.50
-0.78%

Investing

The Most and Least Exposed Insurance Earnings Risk from Hurricane Sandy

Photo of Jon C. Ogg
By Jon C. Ogg Updated Published
Follow 24/7 Wall St. on Google
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.

flickr / gsfc
Earlier today we outlined some of the risks which were seen in overseas trading of the Property & Casualty (P&C) insurance sector and for the reinsurance sector. Now we have seen some larger and much more specific estimates in the worst case and in the base case scenario for insurers due to Hurricane Sandy which were published by Credit Suisse. The earnings damage is put at up to a $30 billion storm cost in the extreme case, but the firm lists a base case scenario of under $10 billion with “considerable uncertainty at this point.”

Be advised that this research report does not exactly target the safest insurers by and large and is not the basis for actual firm ratings of Outperform, Neutral, and Underperform.

Credit Suisse pointed out that only Katrina and Andrew have caused an insured loss of over $20 billion (Katrina- $48 B; Andrew- $25 B). Irene was noted as having a similar path as Sandy causing some $4.3b to $5.0 billion of insured losses. Hurricane Ike caused $13 billion, Wilma caused $12 billion, and Charley caused $9 billion.

Credit Suisse outlined the insurers including ACE Limited (NYSE: ACE), The Allstate Corporation (NYSE: ALL), The Chubb Corporation (NYSE: CB), Cincinnati Financial Corp. (NASDAQ: CINF), Progressive Corp. (NYSE: PGR), The Travelers Companies, Inc. (NYSE: TRV), XL Group plc (NYSE: XL), Arch Capital Group Ltd. (NASDAQ: ACGL), Aspen Insurance Holdings Ltd. (NYSE: AHL), Validus Holdings, Ltd. (NYSE: VR), PartnerRe Ltd. (NYSE: PRE), Platinum Underwriters Holdings Ltd. (NYSE: PTP), American International Group, Inc. (NYSE: AIG), and The Hartford Financial Services Group, Inc. (NYSE: HIG).

Insurers such as Progressive Corp. (NYSE: PGR), Progressive Corp. (NYSE: PGR), and Ace Limited (NYSE: ACE) are all expected to lose less than 25% of their fourth quarter earnings under the first scenario. Sadly, Hartford Financial Services Group, Inc. (NYSE: HIG) could face more than an 80% loss to earnings, Arch Capital Group Ltd. (NASDAQ: ACGL) and The Allstate Corporation (NYSE: ALL) could lose over 90% of their projected fourth quarter earnings per share, and finally The Chubb Corporation (NYSE: CB) could face losses equating to more than 100% of its projected fourth quarter earnings.

Here is a table showing the “potential earnings per share impact” if the hurricane and storm damages reach $10 billion:

Credit Suisse said, “We anticipate reinsurance to start kicking in for Allstate and Chubb when industry losses approach $20-$30bn. In addition, Travelers’ reinsurance program has a minimum retention of $1.5 billion, compared to $500 million for Allstate and Chubb. Therefore, we do not expect Travelers to have much reinsurance protection in the event that Sandy losses are under $10 billion.” Credit Suisse also said that its loss estimates for reinsurers are said to be much less scientific.

As you can tell this is just one report and from just one firm. Estimates may likely vary greatly from source to source.

JON C. OGG

Photo of Jon C. Ogg
About the Author Jon C. Ogg →

Jon Ogg has been a financial news analyst since 1997. Mr. Ogg set up one of the first audio squawk box services for traders called TTN, which he sold in 2003. He has previously worked as a licensed broker to some of the top U.S. and E.U. financial institutions, managed capital, and has raised private capital at the seed and venture stage. He has lived in Copenhagen, Denmark, as well as New York and Chicago, and he now lives in Houston, Texas. Jon received a Bachelor of Business Administration in finance at University of Houston in 1992. a673b.bigscoots-temp.com.

Featured Reads

Our top personal finance-related articles today. Your wallet will thank you later.

Retirees Are Realizing a $1.5 Million Nest Egg at 60 Only Means $31,000 in Real Annual Spending
Drew Wood |

Retirees Are Realizing a $1.5 Million Nest Egg at 60 Only Means $31,000 in Real Annual Spending
71% of Americans With Financial Advisors Feel Secure. Only 10% Without One Do
David Beren |

71% of Americans With Financial Advisors Feel Secure. Only 10% Without One Do

Continue Reading

Jon C. Ogg |

Insurers with Largest and Least Earnings Risk from Hurricane Sandy

The preliminary estimates for the damage of Hurricane Sandy seem to be coming in the $5 billion to $10 billion range.…
Jon C. Ogg |

Counter-Intuitive: Insurance Stocks Rising After Hurricane (ALL, TRV, CB, HIG, BRK-B, RE, PRE, CRD-B)

Any time a hurricane hits, it can cause billions of dollars in damage to homes, cars, businesses, and other properties. …
Jon C. Ogg |

After Hurricane Irene, Tropical Storm Katia Poses Next Threat (ALL, TRV, CB, ALL, BRK-B, RE, PRE, CRD-B, LOW, HD)

The worst part about hurricane season is that one bad hurricane has no impact on whether or not another hurricane,…
Jon C. Ogg |

Insurers Bracing and Prepping for Hurricane Sandy

If Hurricane Sandy remains a Category 1 hurricane, property and casualty insurers may end up be on the hook for…
Could Hurricane Irma Cause $125 Billion in Insured Damages?
Jon C. Ogg |

Could Hurricane Irma Cause $125 Billion in Insured Damages?

Credit Suisse has issued some initial views on what to expect from damages on the insurance side of the equation…
Jon C. Ogg |

Top Analyst Upgrades and Downgrades (ALU, CTRP, D, FLTX, IDTI, NANO, ODFL, RVBD, S, UBS, VLO, DIS, WU, AAPL, ACI, OFC, ARR, ISRG, LOCK, PCS, WIT, LAD, ALL, URI, MPC)

Jon OggThe top analyst upgrades, downgrades and initiations seen in Wall St. research calls will be playing catch-up on Wednesday…
Insurers Bracing for Hurricane Florence, More Storm Threats Coming
Jon C. Ogg |

Insurers Bracing for Hurricane Florence, More Storm Threats Coming

The property and casualty insurers often see their shares trade lower ahead of and into major storms because the losses…
Jon C. Ogg |

Company Winners & Losers Expected From Hurricane Irene (ALL, TRV, CB, BRK-A, DUK, D, ETR, AWK, VZ, HD, LOW, URI, PPG, BECN, IBI, BGG, GNRC, CRD-B, CLH, NYX, NDAQ)

Will Hurricane Irene cost the United States $10 billion? $15 billion? Or even more?  It really depends upon whom you…
5 Insurers Set to Outperform Estimates This Earnings Season
247patrick |

5 Insurers Set to Outperform Estimates This Earnings Season

Insurers are likely to deliver improved investment results.

Top Gaining Stocks

Cboe Global Markets
CBOE • Vol: 1,568,143
New Pluto Global
PSKY • Vol: 12,285,993
Seagate Technology
STX • Vol: 7,378,346
Oracle
ORCL • Vol: 26,317,675
Datadog
DDOG • Vol: 6,247,779

Top Losing Stocks

LKQ
LKQ • Vol: 4,367,433
Clorox
CLX • Vol: 13,260,523
Stryker
SYK • Vol: 4,519,455
Mohawk Industries
MHK • Vol: 1,859,865
Amgen
AMGN • Vol: 3,818,618