Cost Plus, Pier 1, & Tuesday Morning Different Paths (CPWM, PIR, TUES, BIG, SHLD)

When we see a blow-up at Tuesday Morning (NASDAQ:TUES) to the tune of this much, we look at other stores.  The truth is that Tuesday Morning is still a clearance center stock like a Big Lots (NYSE:BIG), although we have noted when we said Big Lots Chart Uglier Than Its Stores that Big Lots is on the lower-end of that quality spectrum.  Big Lots shares are down almost 3% at $16.30 at a new 52-week low in sympathy, although the drop in Tuesday Morning (NASDAQ:TUES) is now over 25% to $4.76 and well under its 52-week trading range of $6.44 to $18.50.
But there are two retail stores that are trading better today. Pier 1 Imports (NYSE: PIR) is seeing shares up some 16% at $3.82 today after competitor Cost Plus (NASDAQ: CPWM) made two consecutive runs.  Shares of Cost Plus Inc. (NASDAQ: CPWM) were just covered by us pre-market Monday in our "10 Stocks Under $10" that we noted favorably.  It isn’t just that we trust the guidance and management saying they are still trying to turn this around and it isn’t that we feel the company will have no exposure to its credit card portfolio.  It is that this trades at enough of a discount to its tangible book value that we feel this stock could continue its recovery.  We were going to list this as one of our turnaround stocks that hasn’t turned around, but it has run more than 20% since Friday’s close.  Maybe this will keep running and maybe it won’t from our $4.39 closing price Friday (although the lowest it traded during market hours on Monday was really $4.41 at the open and it closed at $5.10). This is not without risk and it has traded this far under $10 for a deserving reason.  We’d wait after the big pop of the last two days, but the worst part of the business may be behind it.

Jon C. Ogg
December 18, 2007

Jon Ogg can be reached at [email protected]; he produces the SPECIAL SITUATION newsletter and he does not own securities in the companies he covers.