Short Sellers Love Upstart Holdings After 38% Gain

By Jordan Chussler Published Jul 18, 11:21AM EDT

Follow 24/7 Wall St. on Google

This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.

Short Sellers Love Upstart Holdings After 38% Gain — © BsWei / Shutterstock.com

Key Points

Investors have been turning to small cap stocks over the past few weeks, with the Russell 2000 Index up 11% so far in July.
If you’re an growth investor you need to grab a copy of 24/7 Wall Street’s brand-new AI report, “The Next NVIDIA.” You’ll discover many other stocks that could benefit from supplying NVIDIA and the next wave of growth in AI trends.

Artificial intelligence is all the rage right now, but with giants like NVIDIA (NASDAQ: NVDA | NVDA Price Prediction) taking it on the chin today, the industry is showing how it is just as prone to pullbacks as any other. Shares of NVDA fell by more than 13% over the past five days, including a staggering 6.64% fall on Wednesday, July 17.

Unfortunately, the same fate — or worse — seems to be in play for a much smaller AI company: Upstart Holdings Inc. (NASDAQ: UPST). The $2.72 billion market cap company has seen its shares rise a prolific 38% over the past month. But by zooming out, the picture becomes much clearer. UPST is down over -21% in 2024, -42% over the past year and -92% from its all-time high price of $390 on Oct. 15, 2021.

As its recent gains do not seem sustainable, short sellers have targeted the company, with 25.159 million of its 87.88 million shares outstanding currently being shorted. That equates to 28.62% of Upstart Holding’s total shares.

An Easy AI Bubble Target
Mike MacKenzie / CC BY 2.0 / Flickr

Upstart Holdings has been a popular name in speculative AI stock circles this year, when shares opened at $38.80 on the first trading day of 2024. Expectations, like for the broader AI industry, were lofty. But disappointing earnings in the first quarter provided a necessary reality check when the company saw an EPS of -31 cents, continuing its trend of negative earnings that has seen it only produce positive results once in the past eight quarters dating to the second quarter of 2022. The consensus EPS forecast for the second quarter of 2024 hardly instills confidence at -34 cents per share.

In the first quarter of the year, Upstart Holdings posted negative revenue of -$7.39 million with its net debt holding steadily above $612.80 million for the fifth consecutive quarter. The company’s burn rate is drawing attention, too. In 2022, it posted free cash flow of -$697.59 million, and in 2023, that figure was -$172.58 million.

Over the past 12 months, insiders have been liquidating their positions, with insider selling outweighing insider buying 97 to 16. Institutional ownership has fallen to 43.95%, and the company’s price-to-earning (P/E) ratio is looking bad and getting worse:

2023 P/E ratio: -11.88
Estimated 2024 P/E ratio: -11.84
Estimated 2025 P/E ratio: -22.19
Estimated 2026 P/E ratio: -47.7

This has resulted in the Wall Street Journal giving UPST a one-year median price target of $18. Shares are currently trading for $30.91, meaning the Journal‘s median target represents 41.76% downside potential.

About the Author Jordan Chussler →

Jordan specializes in a wealth of finance topics, ranging from traditional equities, income investment vehicles and alternative assets to retirement savings, debt-based fixed-income securities and commodities, with a specific focus on gold and other precious metals. He takes pride in combining his personal interests and professional experience in finance and education to help readers increase their financial literacy and make better investment choices. Jordan has worked in digital publishing for 17 years after graduating from Lynn University as a member of both the Kappa Delta Pi International Honor Society and the U.S. Achievement Academy's All-American Scholar Program. He is the investing and banking editor for Money and previously served as managing editor of Weiss Ratings. As a contributing writer for BetterInvesting Magazine, Jordan covered topics focused on the fundamentals of investing, technical and fundamental analysis, mutual funds, debt securities, dividend investing, retirement savings strategies and passive income generation. His bylines can be seen at Nasdaq.com, Apple News, Money, MSN, BetterInvesting Magazine, Money Crashers, TipRanks, the Miami Herald and a dozen other newspapers.