This $10.2 Billion ETF Tries to Beat the Market Through Size and Profitability Tilts (But VTI Costs Less)

Photo of Michael Williams
By Michael Williams Published

Quick Read

  • DFAU has returned 91% since November 2020 versus 85% for the S&P 500 by tilting toward smaller companies and higher profitability firms.

  • The fund charges 0.12% annually compared to VTI’s 0.03%. Over decades that 0.09% difference compounds.

  • Technology represents 31% of holdings with the top 10 positions at 38% combined weight.

This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
This $10.2 Billion ETF Tries to Beat the Market Through Size and Profitability Tilts (But VTI Costs Less)

© bigjom jom / Shutterstock.com

Total market equity funds promise broad diversification at rock-bottom fees. Dimensional US Core Equity Market ETF (NYSEARCA:DFAU | DFAU Price Prediction) delivers that while adding subtle factor tilts designed to capture higher expected returns without straying from market weights. For investors seeking core US equity exposure with a research-driven edge, that combination matters.

What DFAU Actually Does

DFAU tracks the broad US equity market with exposure to over 3,000 companies, similar to Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF (NYSEARCA:VTI). The difference lies in execution. While VTI follows strict market-cap weighting, DFAU applies Dimensional Fund Advisors’ academic research to tilt toward smaller companies, lower relative prices, and higher profitability firms. These adjustments happen daily within a framework designed to maintain low tracking error.

Since inception in November 2020, DFAU has returned 91% compared to the S&P 500’s 85%. That 6.4 percentage point outperformance reflects the cumulative benefit of the fund’s approach, though past results don’t guarantee future outcomes. The fund charges 0.12% annually and maintains 4% portfolio turnover, making it highly tax-efficient for taxable accounts.

Where It Fits Best

DFAU works as a single-fund US equity core holding for investors who want market exposure with a tilt toward academic factors associated with higher long-term returns. The $10.2 billion in assets and 0.12% expense ratio make it suitable for portfolios of any size. With 31% allocated to technology and mega-cap names like Nvidia (NASDAQ:NVDA), Apple (NASDAQ:AAPL), and Microsoft (NASDAQ:MSFT) representing 18% of holdings, the fund maintains enough similarity to standard benchmarks that performance won’t diverge dramatically.

The fund pays quarterly dividends that have grown from $0.33 per share in 2021 to $0.45 in 2025, providing modest income alongside capital appreciation.

The Tradeoffs You Accept

Factor tilts introduce tracking error. When large-cap growth stocks dominate, as they did through much of 2023 and 2024, DFAU may lag pure market-cap weighted funds. The recent flat year-to-date performance of 0.05% illustrates this dynamic. Investors must accept periods where the strategy underperforms in exchange for potential long-term benefits of factor exposure.

The fund’s 31% concentration in technology creates sector-specific risk. With top holdings heavily weighted toward AI and semiconductor companies, a sector rotation away from tech would impact performance. The 38% combined weight of the top 10 holdings also means individual company events matter.

Who Should Look Elsewhere

Investors seeking the absolute lowest cost should choose VTI at 0.03% instead of DFAU’s 0.12%. While the difference seems small, over decades that 0.09% adds up, and there’s no guarantee DFAU’s factor tilts will continue delivering outperformance.

Active traders and those focused on short-term performance should avoid DFAU. The factor-based approach requires patience through underperformance cycles. Investors who panic during periods when value or small-cap stocks lag will abandon the strategy at the wrong time.

Consider VTI as an Alternative

VTI offers similar broad market exposure at 0.03%, one-quarter of DFAU’s fee. With $2.1 trillion in assets and a 24-year track record, VTI provides unmatched liquidity and the purest market-cap weighted exposure available. The fund’s 2% turnover beats even DFAU’s 4% rate, potentially offering slightly better tax efficiency.

The tradeoff is simplicity versus sophistication. VTI delivers exactly what the market returns. DFAU attempts to beat the market through factor tilts, which has worked since inception but adds complexity and slightly higher costs. For investors who prefer matching market returns over the possibility of modest outperformance, VTI makes sense.

DFAU works best as a core holding for patient investors who understand factor investing and accept short-term tracking error for potential long-term gains, but the higher fee and factor risk mean it’s not for everyone.

Photo of Michael Williams
About the Author Michael Williams →

I am a long time investor and student of business, and believe finding good companies that can become great investments is the best game on earth. After 20 years of writing and researching the public markets it is clear that individuals have never had more tools and information to take control of their financial lives. From ETFs and $0 commissions to cryptos and prediction markets there has never been a greater democratization of access to investing. 

I write to help people understand the investments available to them so they can make the best choice for their portfolio, whether they're starting out or looking for income in retirement. 

Featured Reads

Our top personal finance-related articles today. Your wallet will thank you later.

Continue Reading

Top Gaining Stocks

CBOE Vol: 1,568,143
PSKY Vol: 12,285,993
STX Vol: 7,378,346
ORCL Vol: 26,317,675
DDOG Vol: 6,247,779

Top Losing Stocks

LKQ
LKQ Vol: 4,367,433
CLX Vol: 13,260,523
SYK Vol: 4,519,455
MHK Vol: 1,859,865
AMGN Vol: 3,818,618